fuse Wrote:
There was another guy who put out two records of Radiohead piano jazz freakouts.
That's Christopher O'Riley. I don't own the albums in question, but I've heard parts of the first one and thought it was okay, not something I'd buy, but it was at least respectable.
fuse Wrote:
Time to move on, people. And as a Radiohead fan, this rankles me a bit. I enjoy Yorke's piano stuff, but it's nowhere on par compositionally with Evans, Brubeck, et al. All this does is further canonizes Rhead a little prematurally in my opinion. Let them write some more good songs before institutionalizing them.
Well, that's the thing - Mehldau's using the Radiohead tunes as jumping off points. Where he takes them is, more often than not, breathtaking. The 20 minute live version of "Paranoid Android" is truly stupendous - he's broken down the melody and slowly rebuilds around it, alternating around the familiar chords for several minutes and then slowly reconstructing the "basic" melody - and then he takes it into space from there once he's established a firm foothold in the song. That's what utilizing a standard ("new standard" or not, I'm simply using this as an example) is about - it's a vehicle for the artist's creativity. That he's chosen Radiohead says a lot about what he thinks their music has to offer him as a launching platform - it offers a very different color than you normally hear from covers of popular songs in the jazz realm.
My only concern with Mehldau is getting stuck in a rut of doing Radiohead tunes - I hear what inspires him in it, but it could easily look like a gimmick to outsiders. Really, I'd like to see more of his own material, like much of
Largo and all of
Places. Covers are great, they're a staple of jazz, but he's a very creative composer in his own right.
Damn, I need to track down that two-disc soundboard Mehldau bootleg I have. It's somewhere mixed in among hundreds (not kidding) of other bootlegs that got disorganized in a recent move . . .