Dusty Choke Wrote:
I just saw Kingdom of Heaven. After Troy and Alexander (and, for that matter, Aviator), I must ask: What. The. Fuck. These are supposed to be some A-grade directors, and they come out with this shit.
Radcliffe, please explain.
It took me 10 years to understand the how (as in HOW a bad movie gets made) and another 10 to come to terms with it - but I still don't understand the why. Seriously, I used to watch film and television and think "fack, I can write better stuff than this." But it turns out that's hardly the point - there's a lot of very bright people out there and ALL of them write better stuff than we're seeing on the screen. The problem, IMO, is that nobody in the film industry likes to read.
There's this thing called "coverage" - and what it means is that when you send a script to a producer or agent, he'll pass it along to a flunky who's paid to read scripts. The flunky (generally a wannabe screenwriter himself) will then write up a criticism and synopsis of the material, and that's the coverage. The coverage is what the producer reads - not the script. Studios have tracking systems to follow coverage. So, say you write a script and send it to ONE producer, who turns it down based on his flunky's coverage. It doesn't matter where you send the script after that - every other producer/studio will read the exact same coverage instead of your script. And, not long ago, you could get around that by changing your title and name on the cover page, but these days they can track coverage based on recurring sentences and plot structure.
So nobody really reads anything. A great deal of films are greenlit on the basis of a pitch and a deal. A pitch like "it's a movie about aliens attacking earth - and it'll star Tom Cruise and will be directed by Spielberg" doesn't require a script. The script is just the bothersome part of the process that has to be begrudgingly attended to before the money starts rolling in.
And, of course, the director is handcuffed by the material. You give Spielberg a good script and he'll make a good movie; you give him a bad script and he'll make a bad movie that looks good. Unfortunately, the good movie and the bad movie generally make the same money at the box office, so there's no real incentive to labor over the minutiae of the script.
Ego, power, greed, and stupidity also play a big role - but that's for some other post.