Planning a vacation with two buddies in the Caribbean. Mid 20s, so looking for a good combo of great beaches, great day trips, and good nightlife / women.

So far this is my short list:
Barbados
Bahamas
Bermuda
Virgin Islands

I have been to Jamaica, so am striking that one.

Anyone have any helpful advice here? Timing would be Mayish

Dominican Republic?

The only place I've been to in the Caribbean is Grand Cayman. I had a blast even though I'm not the beach type. Stringray City is a must see.

I'd love to go back, but it's incredibly expensive.