AMG Review by Tim Sendra
Consistency is troublesome thing, especially in the pop music game. You could deliver nothing but solidly great albums filled with bracing emotion, sparkling melodies, imaginative arrangements and heartfelt performances and be written off as the same old thing while other bands with one-tenth the imagination and power you have gain the accolades and sales you deserve. Consider Mac McCaughan's case. His bands Superchunk and now Portastatic have been shining beacons of consistent greatness and apart from the beginning of Superchunk's career, his work has been mostly overlooked and under-rated. Sometimes in favor of flavor of the month bands (see Arcade Fire) on his own label Merge! For those who have stuck with Mac throughout the years, the last Portastatic album, Bright Ideas, was the big payoff as it was an astoundingly powerful record that spoke the truth about love and life and did so beautifully both musically and lyrically. Well, there's more where that came from because Be Still Please is another brilliant album. It's packed again with Mac's thoughtful and evocative lyrics, his one of a kind voice that seemingly grows stronger with each release and nothing but memorable and moving songs. From the tender ballads (Sweetness and Light,) wrecked ballads (Getting Saved) and intimate ballads (Like a Pearl) to mid-tempo mini-epics (Sour Shores), midnight confessions (Cheers and Applause) and possibly the catchiest rocker Mac has even penned I'm In Love (With Arthur Dove), this is an album the lucky few who hear it will embrace like an old friend. Like an old friend who keeps getting more interesting as time goes on, who makes some positive changes to an already rock-solid friendship, Mac adds some new touches on Be Still Please. There are very sweet female backing vocals provided by Laura Cantrell and Annie Hayden throughout and an overdubbed string section that both provides atmosphere and an extra layer of emotion as well as taking the place of guitars at times (the strings on Sour Shores sound just like a Superchunk riff). Most noticeably, while the songs themselves are less guitar based, Mac unleashes his guitar soloing skills on many of the them, sounding like a pint sized cross between J. Mascis and Neil Young especially on the rousing finish of You Blanks. Add these fantastic updates to an already winning formula and you get an album that should be raved about and loved by blogs, TV networks and the indie kids in dorms, the streets and worldwide. Will it? Doubtful. But for those who are in the know, Be Still Please is another hidden treasure from one of the truly important bands, and person, in pop music today.