two mixes i made recently with a broken relationship in mind. i liked them a lot at first, but revisiting them a few weeks later, i'm not so sure...

cry yourself to sleep
Ode to Divorce - Regina Spektor
Just Like Christmas - Low
I Just Don't Think I'll Ever Get Over You - Colin Hay
Metarie - Brendan Benson
Fall in Love - Tim Booth
Brothers On A Hotel Bed - Death Cab
The Movies - Earlimart
I'm Going to Stop Pretending That I Didn't Break Your Heart - Eels
Let's Get Lost - Elliott Smith
Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) - Arcade Fire
Your Ex-Lover Is Dead - Stars
The Idea of Growing Old - the Features
My Little Red Book - Love
Us - Stephen Malkmus & the Jicks
Only With You - Teenage Fanclub

it's a brand new day
Good To Me - Brendan Benson
Breathless - Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds
If - The Darling Buds
I'd Rather Dance With You - Kings of Convenience
Things the Grandchildren Should Know - Eels
Quit Barking at Me - Jim & Jennie & the Pinetops
Panda - Dungen
This Year - Mountain Goats
Pure - Lightning Seeds
I Ain't Saying My Goodbyes - Tom Vek
The Sweat Descends - Les Savy Fav
Bag Inc - Scene Creamers
Can't Exist - Joseph Arthur
Remember Me - the Zutons
Jesus Everyday - Treat Her Right

Cool concept -- I made a mix that was my attempt to make the saddest mix ever, and called it What I Was Listening To The Night I Broke Up With You/...The Night You Broke Up With Me/...The Night We Broke Up (different titles depending on where you look for the title).

Too bad I'm not familiar with most of the songs.