druucifer Wrote:
andyfest Wrote:
Also, it's been done to death. Protest songs aren't interesting or new like they were in the 50s and 60s, orginized protests all look the same and the only people who pay attention to them are the one's who agree with the protest. The others just ignore it.
bingo. it's the type of people that i've encountered at protests that keep me, somebody who is very much interested in politics and sympathetic to the aims of lots of protestors, from marching in the streets. i went to several anti-war protests in the run-up to iraq, and they obviously didn't help anything. the rambling, un-focused speeches by these ridiculously self-righteous activists didn't inspire or motivate me. and people can't ever seem to stay on topic. the last thing i need to hear is how the war on iraq is an example of the need for worker solidarity or insidious hetero-patriarchy or the rape of the environment. and these sort of arguments do nothing but preach to the choir, which is totally ineffective if the idea is to convince the people who don't already agree with you.
i just get sick of the utopian bullshit. we're never going to live in a world free from violence, the state will not be smashed, we will not form small self-governing autonomous collectives. no matter how broken you think the system is, the fact is that change is possible, and that reforms can be made that will concretely improve people's lives. thats why i'm a liberal rather than a radical: it's a no-brainer when the choice is between bad and slightly better. i just feel like a lot of these activists are more concerned with ideological purity than making somebody's life better.
Completely agree. And another dimension of that is that, for example here in the protests against voluntary student unionism in universities, these protests get hijacked by people not only wanting to push their own agenda, but who provoke violence, or allow themselves to be put into a position where police can justify using roughhouse tactics fairly easily.
In the end all they do is obscure the whole point of the protest, cos when it gets reported on in a 30 second grab on primetime news, you can be sure that the actual issue isn't going to grab the headlines, but the violent minority and arrests of people. So in the minds of the majority of the population, what is often valid questioning of the government can be pigeon-holed as coming from the "radical left" types, not your average left-leaning person who may also agree with it.
Um, yeah, not sure if that really makes sense but hopefully you get my point. The Socialist Alternative types on campus tend to piss me off even while I often agree with the general thrust of their argument (well, not including the socialist part. I think it's pretty obvious that's not going to work anytime soon)