The Mayor of Simpleton Wrote:
Danny Don't Rapp Wrote:
Now that I think about it, I always think it's weird how much shit the Illusion albums get. Maybe it's because I've been listening to them literally since I was a little kid (my parents played them to no end when they came out), but even if I was hearing them for the first time now, I think I'd consider both of them classics. Yeah, they're overblown, bloated, etc., but even the "lesser" songs are really good in my opinion.
How old are you? "Little kid" to me equals about 6. Just curious, it helps get a frame of reference.
I was four or five when they came out.
The Mayor of Simpleton Wrote:
Anyway, yeah, they're better albums than most people want to give them credit for being, but they should have been condensed to one album and the rest released as a separate, lesser album or just b-sides. Which songs, I don't know at the moment, I haven't listened to either in a long time. Neither even remotely approach Appetite in monumentalness, however, and while that album is incredible, the strength of the majority of Maiden's catalog outweighs that one album. Maiden is one bad-ass band - very little crap in that catalog, and what little there is happened in the decade of the 90s. They have probably the greatest 5-album stretch that I know of (Number of the Beast, Piece of Mind, Powerslave, Somewhere In Time, and Seventh Son. I only leave out Live After Death because it's live, not because it's not kick-ass.) You could even make an argument to throw in the first two albums - they're pretty damned awesome, too.
And having great taste means nothing if they turn out a terrible covers album with that material. Lots of bands have great taste. Doesn't mean they're all great.
I actually like the Spaghetti Incident, but I know most people hate it, which is why I phrased that the way I did. The covers aren't mindblowing or anything and they're all pretty faithful to the originals, but there's a couple I actually like better than the originals and they introduced me to some pretty great music when I was 11 or 12.
Maiden just doesn't do it for me for some reason. I certainly don't mind them and I own most of their 80s albums (
Powerslave excluded, which many people consider their best) but I just don't "get it." They're enjoyable, but they've never struck me as anything more than slightly above-average.