DumpJack Wrote:
cemeterypolka Wrote:
DumpJack Wrote:
cemeterypolka Wrote:
I know a lot of people, if you sat them down and made them listen to both artists they'd choose Green Day over Tom Waits, because people hold different opinions.
You play Green Day's Dookie for a bunch of people and then play anything by Waits, what the hell do you think they'll pick? Most people would choose Green Day over Waits because the former have written some upbeat, dumb and catchy tunes, while the latter has an annoying voice with some pretentious, maudlin' songs.
Are we really going to sit here and compare Green Day and Tom Waits?
It's not fair in the first place, and really I was just using Green Day as an example because they're popular in general and really popular with people my age.
You brought it up, but honestly so what if people your age listen to Green Day or whatever the fuck. Let them listen to whatever makes them happy. If that's Green Day great, if god forbid, it's Tom Waits or whoever, super.
But to your earlier post, why the fuck would Tom Waits be "obviously" better than Green Day? Because he's some grizzled old guy which automatically grants him wisdom through song, which passes on to you the listener?
Tom Waits is better to me, "obviously"... I didn't say that was everyones opinion. Yeah I brought it up but I didn't think i'd get some drawn out discussion about it. I was just using Green Day as an example. It could have been Yellowcard or Simple Plan. They're pretty popular. Fall Out Boy? My Chemical Romance? Blink 182? Want me to keep naming bands? Can you defend all of those bands? Would you say you like those bands better than Tom Waits? Why aren't we discussing why Destiny's Child is better than Tom Waits? If Green Day is a fair comparison why can't we compare "Jockey Full Of Bourbon" to "Bootylicious"??
Tom Waits hasn't always been "some grizzled old guy" in fact he put out one of my favorite albums in 1974, The Heart Of Saturday Night. He was what, almost 30 then? I'd say that's pretty young. He's a good storyteller, I like his voice, his style of music.
Yeah, when did I say people can't listen to what makes them happy? That's exactly what i'm doing with listening to Tom Waits so why don't you shut the fuck up with that side of the argument.