From your original description, it does not sound like you said anything truly bad about your friend. A true friend is one who will tell you when you have broccoli stuck in your teeth.
I have a friend who's in a band, and he's a great songwriter, excellent producer (at least demo quality, if not fully releasable quality -- I certainly have no negative criticisms of his production ability, as a matter of fact, I want him to produce me when I'm ready), and to top it all off, he's prolific as hell. The only problem is, because of a certain situation, he hasn't released a single album. I keep harping on him to do so, and this is the sort of thing that might've been in a similar email, had I been in your shoes. As far as I am concerned, you have a burden lifted from you -- you can now be totally honest (without being destructive) with your in-band friend.
Don't know what to do about the editor, though -- sounds like a typical manager-type -- delegate duty, delegate responsibility, and when the shit hits the fan, delegate blame. I've never known how to deal with those people.
katie, a princess Wrote:
i can write 1400 words on a band, no sweat. but there's a point when all you've got is gibberish, superfluous quotes and fluff.
Pitchfork explained.