Moxie Wrote:
While American Water is a fine record, Natural Bridge is my favorite of the Joos output, one that's grossly overlooked as Berman's 2nd or 3rd best. Berman is a champion wordsmith (and a relatively decent poet), but his writing talents don't always translate well when put to music. I love some deadpan in my lyrics as much as the next Ween or Frogs fan, but the latter half of A. Water starts to grate on my nerves as the Joos formula goes a bit stale (save Honk if you're Lonely...). I like this record, but overall it lacks the grit (BAllad of Rev. War Character) & honesty (Inside the Golden Days of Missing YOu) of Natural Bridge - you can actually detect Berman growing and improving as a serious musician. I don't get that at all with the Malkmus-enhanced A. Water.
Natural Bridge
American Water
Bright Flight
Also, check out his 2003 book of prose, Actual Air. Skillz dat pay da billz.
TN came in #10, I think, on my '05 list.
Yeah,
Actual Air is great. I'd kinda forgotten about it lately. I should read it again.
I've kinda gone back and forth between picking
Natural Bridge and
American Water as favorites. Lately I've settled on the latter just due to all-around goodness. I don't really think the second half is stale in the least. I really like "Buckingham Rabbit", "The Wild Kindness", and "Send in the Clouds" a lot. I wouldn't say
Natural Bridge is "grossly overlooked" although I'd agree it's a little underrated. Most people do seem to pick the albums with Malkmus as favorites, but I just can't deny the greatness of
American Water (also far and away the best thing Malkmus has been involved in since
Wowie Zowee).