So far tonight...

Alright, I'm done with Ace. He can do that "look" at the end of his songs all he wants, it's over.

Ole Pickler: I mean she's cute, but she's just not that good. And this is a singing competition.

Elliott: Dude can sing his ass off. But not tonight. And that underbite is f-ing KILLING ME! Naw but, he deserves to be where he is right now.

Bucky + Steve Wonder Song is going to be a trainwreck.

I mean...I don't get it. They tear people on here apart when they can actually sing and then this douche comes on and they say they enjoyed it.

You know for a fact that if given the choice between being able to see and not hearing this dude tear his song apart he'd choose...ah forget it.

YOU FORGOT THE WORDS! GOD YOU SUCK!

that was the only interesting part of the whole thing.
she's terrible.

and yet randy said she can sing. weirdo.

simon liked that too? are these people deaf?

I seriously wanted to kill Randy three episodes into this season. I'm sick to death of his corny ass catch phrases he peppers in any chance he gets.

I wish I could throw my cell phone at her.

I actually think they've ALL been terrible tonight. It's painful.

Yeah, pretty much. Lisa isn't that bad right now, but it's still a boring performance. I'm waiting for my favorites, Katharine and Taylor.

Yeah this is not a good way to kick of the final 12.

There's a good reason why Stevie's the best. His shit is hard. But I can hear this crap in a bar.

You when Harry Potter left the room he was like "Alright seriously what the fuck am I doing here?".

But I gotta tell ya, he wasn't the worst tonight.

yeah, it's really hard to top stevie on his own songs.
his melodies are so perfect . . . what can you do with it but remind me how you aren't stevie.

so who is going to mangle "overjoyed"

Someone already tried that this season. Maybe Sway? But it love for someone to pull it off. But if you can't then just sing I Just Called To Say I Love You and get off the stage.

Busty, if Taylor Hicks can make it this far, you could win this bitch!

(GETTHEGUNGETHEGUN. SHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOT)

I'm beginning to think this Cathy chick can make it to the final 2.

Yeah, that was the only one so far that didn't make me leave the room to go get something to drink. Suffice to say, I'm feeling pretty juiced.

Hicks was the best by far tonight. That was pretty damn good.

I think it's between him and the chick before him. Yeah that was great.

Something about this Paris girl scares the absolute shit out of me. I can't explain it...I mean her speaking voice is TOTALLY different from her singing voice.

I mean she's good, don't get me wrong. But she's just...wierd.

Tonight was the first time Paris actually made any kind of impression with me, she was good. But I definately agree with the weird thing. Keep the singing to the actual performance, broad.

paris is the clear winner in my mind. no one else is anywhere close.

has simon never heard the chili peppers version?
how did he "make that his own"

Thought the same thing when he said that.

Yep, that was right off Mother's Milk.

Best performance of the night goes to Taylor Hicks.

Paris Bennett and Katherine McPhee tied for second. And Elliott Yamin in third.

That Chris guy annoys the crap of out of me. Singing 'Higher Ground' as opposed to tackling another Stevie Wonder song was a cop out.