For the truly hardcore, here is a personal rankings list from a fellow's web site:
Anthony's Rankings
rank soda rating
1. Bulldog Handcrafted Root Beer 98
2. Boylan's Natural Root Beer 98
3. Boylan's Creamy Red Birch Beer 96
4. Ithaca Soda Co Root Beer 96
5. Boylans Original Birch Beer 95
6. Howie's Root Beer 95
7. Sparky's Fresh Draft Root Beer 95
8. Bad Bob's Root Beer 95
9. Root 66 Root Beer 94
10. Saranac 1888 Root Beer 94
11. AJ Stephans OIde Style Sarsaparilla 94
12. Capt'n Eli's Root Beer 94
13. Jackson Hole Soda Company Buckin' Rootbeer 94
14. Bennett's Big Bear Root Beer 94
15. Millstream Old Time Rootbeer 93
16. Kutztown Original Premium Recipe Birch Beer 93
17. Jumpin Johnny's Root Beer 93
18. Empire Bottling Works Rootbeer 93
19. Syracuse Suds Factory Root Beer 93
20. Alder Brau Root Beer 92
21. Lost Trail Root Beer 92
22. Cody Blake's Original Microbrewed Root Beer 92
23. Shotz Root Beer 92
24. Butthead Brand Root Beer 92
25. Bluegrass Brewing Co Root Beer 92
26. Mt Tom Beverage Co Rollie's Root Beer 92
27. Hank's Premium Philadelphia Birch Beer 91
28. Coastal Fog Draught Style Root Beer 91
29. A-Treat Birch Beer 91
30. Clover Classic Premium Root Beer 91
31. Steelhead Original Spicy Draft Root Beer 91
32. Hosmer Mountain Sarsaparilla Root Beer 91
33. Page Brewing Dorothy's Isle of Pines Root Beer 91
34. Hank's Premium Philadelphia Recipe Root Beer 90
35. Olde Brooklyn Bayridge Birch Beer 90
36. Gilded Otter Barley's Rootbeer 90
37. AJ Stephans Pure Cane Sugar Birch Beer 90
38. Bedford's Gourmet Root Beer 90
39. Mug N Bun Root Beer 90
40. S&O'K Root Beer 89
41. Sprecher Root Beer Soda 89
42. Fitz's Root Beer 89
43. Sioux City Root Beer 89
44. Point Premium Root Beer 89
45. Blumers Root Beer 89
46. Maine Root. Organic Sarsaparilla 89
47. Baron's Boothill Sarsaparilla 88
48. Briar's Birch Beer 88
49. Henry Weinhard Premium Draught Style Head Root Beer 88
50. Briar's Cane Sugar Premium Root Beer 88
51. AJ Stephans Old Style Root Beer 88
52. Forest Park Root Beer 88
53. Goose Island Root Beer 87
54. Olde Brooklyn Williamsburg Root Beer 87
55. Kutztown Original Premium Recipe Sarsaparilla 87
56. Foxon Park White Birch 87
57. Empire Bottling Works Sarsaparilla 87
58. Gene's Root Beer 87
59. Zota Green Tea Soda Root Beer 87
60. Thorpe's Root Beer 86
61. Sonora Brewing Company Root Beer 86
62. Old Soaker Root Beer 86
63. A-Treat Sarsaparilla 86
64. Forest Park Birch Beer 86
65. Baumeister Root Beer 86
66. Journey Sassafras Root Beer 86
67. Spring Grove Root Beer 85
68. Americana Microcrafted Cream Style Root Beer 85
69. Frostie Root Beer 85
70. Maine Root. Handcrafted Rootbeer 85
71. Harpoon Brewery Vermont Draft Root Beer 85
72. AJ Stephans Pure Cane Sugar Root Beer 85
73. Two Bellies Root Beer 85
74. Big Ben's Root Beer 85
75. Abita Root Beer 84
76. Briar's Root Beer 84
77. Dog n Suds Draft Style Root Beer 84
78. Milligan's Island Root Beer 84
79. Old Original Levis Root Beer Soda 84
80. Gray's Great American Root Beer 83
81. Dave and Buster's Old Fashioned Philly Root Beer 83
82. Hosmer Mountain Root Beer 83
83. Tops Market Root Beer 83
84. Foxon Park Draft Style Root Beer 83
85. Hosmer Mountain Sarsaparilla 83
86. Big Ben's Blue Birch Beer 83
87. Big Ben's White Birch Beer 83
88. A-Treat Root Beer 83
89. Private Label Sarsaparilla 82
90. Spike's Root Beer 82
91. Old Dominion Root Beer 82
92. Druthers Black Cow Vanilla Creme Rootbeer 82
93. Iron Horse Root Beer 82
94. Cott Premium Draft Root Beer 82
95. Lafayette Brewing Co Old Fashioned Rootbeer 82
96. Frozen Run Black Bear Mountain Birch Beer 81
97. Oop! Juice Root Beer 81
98. Sioux City Sarsaparilla 81
99. Pennsylvania Dutch Red Birch Beer 81
100. Kay Koola Premium Root Beer 81
101. Monterey Soda Root Beer 81
102. Cooper's Cave Ale Company Sarsaparilla 81
103. Journey Birch Beer 81
104. Crazy Ed's Root Beer 80
105. Scooter's Root Beer 80
106. SodaWerks White Tail Birch Beer 80
107. Tommy's Naked Soda Righteous Root Beer 80
108. BK Root Beer 80
109. Flossmoor Station Goober Brau Root Beer 80
110. Squeeze Birch Beer 79
111. Hansen's Signature All Natural Sarsaprilla Soda 79
112. Hot Rod Magazine Root Beer 79
113. Black Cow Root Beer 78
114. Canfield's Root Beer 78
115. Mad River Root Beer 78
116. O'Sippie Root Beer 78
117. Score Root Beer 78
118. Briar's Cane Sugar Premium Red Birch Beer 78
119. Cooper's Creek Ale Company Root Beer 78
120. Lion Brewery Root Beer 77
121. Thomas Kemper Pure Draft Root Beer 77
122. Pennsylvania Dutch Sparkling Birch Beer 76
123. Tommyknocker Root Beer 76
124. Roundhouse Rootbeer 76
125. Pearson Bros. Root Beer 75
126. Squeeze Root Beer 75
127. Sainsbury's Root Beer 75
128. Filbert's Olde Time Quality Draft Root Beer 75
129. Cooper's Cave Ale Company Birch Beer 75
130. Napa Valley Soda Co Root Beer 75
131. Weis Choice White Birch Beer 75
132. IBC Root Beer 74
133. Oop! Juice Birch Beer 74
134. Stone Creek Root Beer 74
135. Berghoff's Root Beer 73
136. Weber's Root Beer 73
137. Briar's Red Birch Beer 73
138. Market Basket Sarsaparilla 73
139. Wildwood Rootbeer 73
140. Mystic Seaport Sarsaparilla 72
141. Private Label Root Beer 72
142. Klenke Root Beer 72
143. Squamscot Old Fashioned Beverages Root Beer 72
144. Dr Brown's Draft Style Root Beer 72
145. Braum's Root Beer 72
146. Victory Super Markets Root Beer 72
147. Weis Choice Birch Beer 72
148. Old Towne Root Beer 72
149. A & W Root Beer 71
150. Cornell Root Beer 71
151. Mason's Root Beer 71
152. Mug Root Beer 70
153. Pirate's Keg Root Beer 70
154. Stewart's Original Birch Beer 70
155. Olde Philadelphia William Penn Root Beer 70
156. Foodtown Birch Beer 69
157. Journey Desert Sage Root Beer 69
158. Hosmer Mountain Birch Beer 69
159. Dr McGillicuddy's Old Fashioned Root Beer 68
160. Hires Root Beer 68
161. Natural Brew Draft Root Beer 68
162. Stewart's Original Root Beer 68
163. Clearwater Rootbeer 68
164. R and B Produce Homemade Root Beer 68
165. Dad's Root Beer 67
166. Sioux City Birch Beer 67
167. Blue Sky Ginseng Root Beer 67
168. Stop & Shop Sarsaparilla 67
169. Cool Mountain Gourmet Soda Root Beer 67
170. Chug's Choice Root Beer 66
171. Shoprite Root Beer 66
172. Spring Spring Root Beer Draft Style 66
173. Best Choice Root Beer 66
174. Food Lion Root Beer 66
175. Hoffman Draft Style Root Beer 65
176. Safeway Select Root Beer 65
177. Stewart's Store Root Beer 65
178. Flathead Lake Monster Rootbeer 65
179. Deep South Premium Old Style Draft Root Beer 65
180. Supervalu Super Chill Root Beer 65
181. Kroger's Big K Root Beer 65
182. Lowes Food Root Beer 65
183. Western Family Root Beer 64
184. Little Jerk Premium Root Beer 64
185. Jack Russell Red Ball Root Beer 64
186. AJ Stephans Pure Cane Sugar Sarsaparilla 64
187. Red & White Root Beer 63
188. Hansen's Natural Creamy Root Beer 63
189. Top Pop Root Beer 63
190. Steap Green Tea Root Beer 63
191. Old Keg Root Beer 62
192. Rock It Root Beer 62
193. President's Choice Old Fashioned Root Beer 62
194. Wil's Old Fashioned Premium Draft Root Beer 62
195. Grand Premium Draft Style Root Beer 61
196. Manhattan Special True Root Sarsaparilla 61
197. Quick Check Root Beer 61
198. Snapple Tru Root Beer 61
199. SodaWerks Buzzy's Root Beer 61
200. Saranac Diet 1888 Root Beer 61
201. Mt. Angel Root beer 60
202. Boylan's Root Beer 60
203. Foodtown Root Beer 60
204. Pennsylvania Dutch Diet Birch Beer 60
205. Weis Choice Diet White Birch Beer 60
206. Harris Teeter Root Beer 60
207. Alco Select Brown Barrel Original Root Beer 60
208. Weis Choice Root Beer 60
209. Wegmans Fountain W Root Beer 59
210. Great Montana Soda Factory Root Beer 59
211. Market Basket Root Beer 59
212. Briar's Diet Root Beer 58
213. Barrel Brothers Root Beer 58
214. Jack Black's Dead Red Root Beer 57
215. Myers Ave Red Root Beer 57
216. Blue Sky Natural Root Beer 56
217. Parade Root Beer 56
218. Crystal Club Birchola 55
219. Jones Root Beer 55
220. Crystal Club Draft Style Root Beer 54
221. Mr. D'z Route 66 Root Beer 54
222. Think! Interactive Root Beer 53
223. Publix Root Beer 53
224. Way 2 Cool Natural Root Beer 52
225. Sarsi Sarsaparilla 51
226. Frank's Draft Root Beer 50
227. Stop & Shop Root Beer 49
228. Sodawerks Sass-parilla 49
229. Shasta Root Beer 48
230. Stars & Stripes Root Beer 47
231. Albertson's A+ Root Beer Old Fashioned Soda 46
232. Deep South Chek Rootbeer 46
233. Gray's Great American Diet Root Beer 46
234. Barq's 45
235. Carters Root Beer 45
236. Kizz Root Beer Flavored Natural Soda 44
237. Trader Joe's Organic Root Beer 44
238. Bundaberg Root Beer 43
239. Publix Diet Root Beer 43
240. Market Basket Birch Beer 43
241. Boylan's Diet Birch Beer 42
242. Faygo Old Fashioned Root Beer Genuine Draft Style 42
243. America's Choice Root Beer 41
244. Dr Tima's Honey Root beer 41
245. Journey Great Northern Root Beer 40
246. Goose Island Diet Root Beer 40
247. Health Valley Old Fashioned Root Beer 39
248. Smart & Final Root Beer 39
249. 365 All Natural Root Beer Soda 38
250. Rite Aid Big Fizz Root Beer 38
251. Ol Bob Miller's Prospector Style Red Sas'parilla 37
252. Best Yet Root Beer 37
253. Eddie Bob's Birch Beer 36
254. Health valley Sarsaparilla Root Beer 36
255. Walgreens Root Beer 36
256. Fitz's Diet Premium Micro-Brewed Root Beer 36
257. Acme Root Beer 35
258. Mercury Brewing Company Birch Beer 35
259. Our Family Root Beer 35
260. Q&V Root Beer 34
261. Terra Soda Root Beer 34
262. Original New York Seltzer Classic Blend Root Beer Sparkling Water 33
263. Olde Brooklyn Diet Williamsburg Root Beer 33
264. C&C Root Beer 32
265. Naturale 90 Root Beer Soda 32
266. Sprecher Lo-Cal Root Beer Soda 32
267. Shasta Diet Root Beer 31
268. Shur Fine Root Beer 31
269. Foxon Park Diet White Birch Beer 31
270. Old Mill Sarsaparilla 30
271. Market Basket Diet Root Beer 30
272. Acme Birch Beer 28
273. Brair's Six Gun Sarsaparilla 28
274. Jewel Root Beer 27
275. Lotsa Diet Root Beer 27
276. Big Y Root Beer 26
277. American Fare Root Beer 26
278. Finast Root Beer 25
279. Trader Joe's Premium Draught Style Root Beer 25
280. Polar Root Beer 24
281. Hey Song Sarsaprilla Drink 24
282. Price Chopper Root Beer 23
283. Sea Dog Root Beer 23
284. Keiko Draft Root Beer 22
285. Sensational Root Beer 22
286. XTZ X Root Beer Riot 22
287. Faygo Diet Root Beer 21
288. Pathmark Old Fashioned Draft Style Root Beer 21
289. RJ Corr Root Beer 21
290. Virgil's Root Beer 21
291. Jeff's Amazing New York Root Beer Float Egg Cream 20
292. Polar Wild West Sarsaparilla 20
293. Hank's Premium Philadelphia Diet Root Beer 20
294. Journey John Barleycorn Root Beer 19
295. Arizona Root Beer Float 18
296. Mystic Seaport Root Beer 17
297. Adirondack Root Beer 16
298. Skeleteen's Rat Bastard Root Beer 16
299. A-Treat Diet Birch Beer 16
300. Hosmer Mountain Diet Root Beer 16
301. IGA Root Beer 15
302. Polar Birch Beer 15
303. Adirondack Waist Watcher Diet Root Beer 15
304. A-Treat Diet Root Beer 15
305. Briar's Diet Birch Beer 14
306. Polar Cape Cod Dry Birch Beer 14
307. Kutztown Diet Birch Beer 14
308. Villa 330 Sarsaparilla 13
309. Cooper's Creek Ale Company Diet Root Beer 13
310. Journey Shenandoah Sassfras Root Beer 12
311. Virgil's Special Edition Bavarian Nutmeg Root Beer 12
312. After The Fall All Natural Diet Root Beer Spritzer 11
313. Mr Fenwick's Traditional Style Sarsaparilla 11
314. Journey Root Beer and Ginseng 10
315. Free Natural Root Beer 9
316. Journey Borealis Birch Beer 8
317. After The Fall Diet Rootbeer 7
318. Pirate's Keg Diet Root Beer 7
319. Pathmark Old Fashioned Draft Style Birch Beer 5
320. Santa Cruz Organic Root Beer 4
321. Free Natural Sasperilla 3
http://rootbeerbarrel.com/master.html?h ... king.shtml