Magnolia Electric Co. -
Josephine (emusic download 7/22/09)
I'd prefer not even acknowledge the existence of this thing, much less write about it. I won't say I had high hopes for it, but I was cautiously optimistic based on the "It's Made Me Cry" 7", the
Sojourner box set, and the amount of time and amount of stuff Molina had been through since the last proper album he put out as MEC (
Fading Trails). The box set made it seem like Molina might finally bring something interesting to the table with the derivative country rock he's been peddling for the past 6 years, especially the
Black Ram disc. Unfortunately, this is probably the worst thing he's done under the Magnolia moniker, and probably the worst thing he's ever put out.
It's so middling and predictable as to be hard to even pay attention to when I'm listening to it. The lyrics shift between the totally clichéd and the nonsensical. Although to be perfectly honest, this is something that has plagued a lot of this guy's work for a long time. And now that he's only backing this up with standard, competent bar band music, it's just overwhelmingly dull. I can't begin to describe how sick I am of hearing the same slide guitar in every single MEC song. Having listened to pretty much his whole discography lately, I think I'm having to face the sad fact that
Didn't It Rain was a fluke, not a height that he may someday reach again or even one that he had really come close to in the past. Still, I'd be perfectly happy with something new on par with
Axxess & Ace,
The Lioness,
Impala or even
Ghost Tropic, but the chances of that are seeming slimmer with each new MEC release. If anything, the stuff released under his own name - and hopefully this Molina & Johnson collaboration - is the best bet for at least measuring up to some of the better Songs: Ohia albums. I may have to give up on Magnolia Electric Co. after this one.
Rating:
5/10
Edit: But I will say that the one glimmer of hope here - if there is one - is the song "Little Sad Eyes" which actually does sound a lot like Songs: Ohia circa
Axxess & Ace. Of course, I don't just want him to go back and remake his old records, but this at least shows that maybe he's not totally tied to his recent country-rock direction and that even with MEC he's capable of maybe doing something just a little bit different. Plus it's a pretty good song.