i floated this idea around a couple times, but no one showed a lot of interest. but now there has been a couple threads like this, so ill ask if people want to do this. of course, i would do all the tabulating, you would just post the list.

i voted no.

en oh.

I doubt if I'd do it, but I'll be interested to see what kind of list comes of this.

i might attempt this if i have enough time at "work" this week....

Well, I just did a Top 50. So I guess that's a yes.

Just do it or don't.

If Stylus and Pitchfork can do it than why can’t us? Like looking at members lists because over the years have gotten to know them. Consequently, enjoy them moreso because of that fact.

No need to tabulate really; I like the individual lists better anyway. A better chance of finding something you haven't heard there. I've found lots of good stuff over the years from people on this site and its predecessor.

I don't have a problem with a 2000-2004 listmania but it would probably take me months to come up with a list and I doubt if there are enough others interested to make it worthwhile.