Dalen Wrote:
I think you're missing the point.
The world's problems won't be solved by t-shirts, buttons, bracelets and posters. A measured reading of history would probably indicate that, more often than not, these things create problems. This is the issue many have with the campaign. Just because middle school kids are now discussing this and their self-righteous elders are responding with 'yes, we must do something! let's throw money at this problem!' doesn't make it OK. Crowdsourcing is fun, and yay, we get to wear cute shirts and seem like we're helping the world to all of our Facebook friends, but realistically, what is this all going to achieve? Do you not realize the negative outcome that may occur?
Instead of sitting there and saying 'hey at least they're doing something', maybe you should understand the history of the region a little bit better and realize the consequences all of this may have. Oh, and question the intentions.
Also, I know it's 'popular' and 'cool' to post about all of the 'work we're doing for human rights', but many do it silently, and don't feel the need for a pat on the back. You should keep that in mind dude.
I'll play devil's advocate.
1. What is the "negative outcome that may occur"? (And is that truly enough to offset any possible positives?)
Invisible Children want you to blindly support Uganda's government and its military adventures beyond its borders. This will almost guarantee more violence in Central Africa. 2. Again, if FR were to do further research into the region, what are the consequences of this that he would discover?
Maybe a deeper understanding of the history of the Acholi people and the LRA would help one realize that this is not a one dimensional issue.3. You suggest he should "question the intentions" so what do you believe the intentions are here?
While I'm sure there are good intentions in some scale, the way this film/campaign is delivered leads me to believe that it has more to do with marketing than solving any issues.4. If you truly believe in something, and you believe the cause needs all the help it can get, why would you support it "silently"? Can you effectively join a fundraising cause while telling no one about it?
You can indeed support silently. Not sure why at your age this would need further explanation.