toots Wrote:
so the price point for quality bourbon is considerably lower than the 80-100 bar i set?
You need to pay up for scotch much more than you do for bourbon. As long as you stay clear of most of the bottom shelf stuff, you're going to get a decent bourbon and there's very good bourbon in the $25-50 price range. I like most Buffalo Trace products (Buffalo Trace, Eagle Rare, WL Weller, Old Weller Antique). Old Weller Antique (probably hard to find now unfortunately) is made at the same distillery as Pappy Van Winkle using essentially the same recipe but only costs $30. Old Bardstown Estate is my regular buy these days and can be had for about $35. Blanton's which Phil recommended is approximately $45.
To pay much more than that and not be paying for just for hype, you need to find an aged bourbon or something cask strength. The problem with that is there isn't much aged bourbon around and even less good aged bourbon. Bourbon doesn't benefit as much from aging beyond 8-12 years as scotch does because by law its aged in new american oak where scotch is aged in used barrels (bourbon, sherry, port, etc). Many of the aged bourbons have been aged too long and are over oaked and the really good ones that are much better than the younger bottles in the $35-50 range are pretty hard to come by these days.
If you're looking for something more special to sip neat, I'd probably just go with one of the scotchs in the $80 -120 range that I recommended. If you would really prefer bourbon, you could look for Maker's Mark's Cask Strength which is supposed to be really good. It sells for around $40 for a 375ml bottle. Not sure you'll find it though. I haven't seen any in months. Diageo has a heavily hyped line of aged bourbon special releases called the "Orphan Barrel" project. They're near the top of that price range and get somewhat mixed reviews but they are old bourbons and some people seem to really like them. I'm skeptical that they are really worth the money though. If you can get to a Binny's, you might find an exclusive bottling that is worth paying up for but as far as general release bottlings I can't think of many special ones that are easy to find.